Blog Layout

Child-Resistant...Not Child-Proof

Mark Perkins • October 17, 2024

Dispelling the Myth: Why There is No Such Thing as Child-Proof Packaging

Dispelling the Myth: Why There is No Such Thing as Child-Proof Packaging


In the realm of product safety, particularly concerning items like medications, household cleaners, and chemicals, the term "child-proof packaging" is commonly used. However, despite its widespread usage, the concept of truly child-proof packaging is a misnomer. Let's delve into why there's no such thing as completely child-proof packaging and what measures can be taken to enhance child safety.

 

The Fallacy of Child-Proof Packaging


The term "child-proof" implies that a packaging solution is entirely impervious to a child's attempts to access its contents. However, in reality, no packaging can guarantee absolute protection against determined children. While some packaging designs may significantly deter children from accessing hazardous substances, no solution can completely eliminate the risk.

 

Understanding Child Development


Children are naturally curious and persistent problem-solvers, traits that can pose challenges when it comes to packaging intended to keep them safe. As they grow and develop, children become increasingly adept at manipulating objects and overcoming obstacles. What may seem insurmountable to a toddler may become conquerable to an older child with more advanced motor skills and cognitive abilities.

 

Child-Resistant vs. Child-Proof


Instead of striving for the unattainable goal of child-proof packaging, industry standards and regulations focus on child-resistant packaging (CRP). Child-resistant packaging is designed to be challenging for young children (42 to 51 months) to open or access, requiring a combination of cognitive ability, physical strength, and dexterity that surpasses their capabilities. However, it's essential to recognize that even child-resistant packaging is not foolproof and may be breached by persistent children given enough time and opportunity.

 

The Role of Caregiver Responsibility


While effective packaging designs play a crucial role in preventing accidental ingestions or exposures, caregiver responsibility remains paramount. Supervision, education, and proper storage of hazardous substances are essential components of a comprehensive child safety strategy. Caregivers must be proactive in keeping potentially harmful products out of reach of children while educating them about the dangers associated with certain items.

 

Enhancing Child Safety Through Innovation


As technology and materials science continue to advance, there are opportunities to enhance child safety through innovative packaging solutions. Improved locking mechanisms, tamper-evident features, and sensory deterrents can all contribute to making packaging more child-resistant. However, it's essential to strike a balance between safety, accessibility for adults, and cost-effectiveness.

 

Conclusion


In the discourse surrounding product safety, it's crucial to dispel the notion of child-proof packaging and instead focus on practical measures to mitigate risks and protect children from harm. While no packaging solution can guarantee absolute safety, advancements in design, coupled with caregiver responsibility and education, can significantly reduce the likelihood of accidental ingestions or exposures. By adopting a multifaceted approach that acknowledges the limitations of packaging and the importance of caregiver vigilance, we can create safer environments for children to thrive.

 

If you have any questions regarding child-resistant packaging and how to prove CR - call Bird Dog Marketing Group, LLC at 1-717-615-9022 or email: sales@birddogmarketinggroup.com.


Bird Dog Marketing Group is an international industry leader in Child Resistant (CR) and Senior Adult Use Effectiveness (SAUE) protocol testing. For over 55 years, we have been providing comprehensive research and testing services and have a track record of success in safety and child-resistant package testing. We have tested and evaluated thousands of different package types, including unit dose packages, pouches, bottles and containers with a variety of closures, aerosol cans, pump dispensers and more. Our team provides an assurance of accuracy and hyper-focused attention to detail for all package testing.


Photo of computer laptop screen, tiny shopping cart holding medicine bottles.
By Mark Perkins March 13, 2025
As e-commerce continues to surge, the importance of child-resistant packaging has never been more critical.
Photograph of colorful question marks and words.
By Mark Perkins November 19, 2024
The Poison Prevention Packaging Act (PPPA), enacted in 1970, is one of the cornerstones of child safety regulations in the United States. Its primary goal is to prevent children from accessing hazardous household substances like medications, household chemicals, and other toxic products. As part of this initiative, the law requires certain products to be packaged in child-resistant containers. The question is: how did the government determine the specific age ranges of children who should be tested for these packaging requirements?
Young child sitting on the floor with open medicine containers.
By Mark Perkins November 4, 2024
The Poison Prevention Packaging Act: A Milestone in Child Safety
Young girl in a ballet outfit sitting on a windowsill looking outside.
By Mark Perkins October 17, 2024
Every year, thousands of children under the age of five face serious health risks due to unintentional poisonings. This article will review the statistics, explain how child-resistant packaging works, and detail how parents can help keep their children safe from accidental poisoning.
People sitting at an expo booth with banner sign behind them requesting help for package testing.
By Mark Perkins June 5, 2024
Our test proctors administering adult-use package testing are often asked, “Why are you only testing adults 50-70 years of age?” Here’s the story behind that decision. When the U.S. Congress passed the Poison Prevention Packaging Act of 1970 (PPPA), the Consumer Product Safety Commission (CPSC) required child-resistant packaging for specific drugs and household chemicals that could harm children. Package manufacturers developed and introduced new child-resistant packaging to comply with the requirements. Per the PPPA, the specialty packaging required certification that they were child-resistant. At the time, the adult-use effectiveness portion of the package test protocols included adult test subjects 18-45 years of age, a significant change from our current adult-use effectiveness subjects who are 50-70.
View of a city looking down from the sky.
By Mark Perkins April 10, 2024
As the world leader in child-resistant and senior-friendly package testing, Bird Dog Marketing Group considers ISO 17025 accreditation an essential requirement for all testing laboratories, and this is why we choose to be audited for accreditation annually. Our global customers have the assurance that they can trust the results we provide to them on every test.
Logo with a sketch of a dog and the letters B and D.
By Beth Mack February 13, 2024
BDMG is proud to celebrate 55 years of child-resistant package testing, continuing Gene Miller's legacy of saving children's lives from accidental poisoning. Many things have changed since the passage of the Poison Prevention Packaging Act of 1970, but the dedication of our team and our clients to working together in the testing of child-resistant packaging has remained the same.
The child is in a car seat, another child is trying to open medicine.
By Beth Mack February 2, 2023
Here is a great resource for tips on protecting your children and grandchildren from accidental poisoning, choking, burns, and other household hazards. It's a reminder of how quickly a child's ability to access potentially harmful situations changes and the need to always be one step ahead! #childsafety #childsafetyandprotectionmonth https://www.safekids.org/safetytips
Face of a woman with short dark hair.
By Beth Mack April 1, 2022
Today we are celebrating our Regional Manager, Julie Burke. Thank you for the important work you are doing to save children from accidental poisoning...you are making a difference.
Computer keyboard with words Product and Recall on Red buttons.
By Beth Mack March 24, 2022
This is an ongoing listing of CPSC Product Recall Information.
More Posts
Share by: